Where does the Shulchan Aruch quote an authority by name?Pesach/Passover Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara Planned maintenance scheduled April 17/18, 2019 at 00:00UTC (8:00pm US/Eastern) Best answer contest: Second quarter of 5779 To celebrate Mi Yodeya's tenth birthday, let's divide and conquer the entire…What rules did Hamechaber set to himself before compiling the Shulchan Aruch?Shulchan Aruch UTF-8Anonymous glosses in the Shulchan AruchWhy is the Shulchan Aruch definitive?Siman 32, Kitzur Shulchan Aruch: UntranslatedLitvaks/Yeshivish and Shulchan AruchBuying a Shulchan AruchEnglish version of SHULCHAN ARUCHIs there any place where Shulchan Aruch rules with the Rosh against the Rif and Rambam?5th part of the shulchan aruchLearning to translate the Shulchan Aruch
Is there any avatar supposed to be born between the death of Krishna and the birth of Kalki?
Why is "Consequences inflicted." not a sentence?
Using et al. for a last / senior author rather than for a first author
What do you call a phrase that's not an idiom yet?
What's the difference between `auto x = vector<int>()` and `vector<int> x`?
Dating a Former Employee
How to recreate this effect in Photoshop?
Problem drawing boxes with arrows in tikZ
Did Kevin spill real chili?
Can inflation occur in a positive-sum game currency system such as the Stack Exchange reputation system?
What is the correct way to use the pinch test for dehydration?
Is there a "higher Segal conjecture"?
Were Kohanim forbidden from serving in King David's army?
iPhone Wallpaper?
List *all* the tuples!
How to motivate offshore teams and trust them to deliver?
Models of set theory where not every set can be linearly ordered
Do I really need recursive chmod to restrict access to a folder?
Why constant symbols in a language?
What happens to sewage if there is no river near by?
Gastric acid as a weapon
Letter Boxed validator
What are the motives behind Cersei's orders given to Bronn?
How to do this path/lattice with tikz
Where does the Shulchan Aruch quote an authority by name?
Pesach/Passover
Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara
Planned maintenance scheduled April 17/18, 2019 at 00:00UTC (8:00pm US/Eastern)
Best answer contest: Second quarter of 5779
To celebrate Mi Yodeya's tenth birthday, let's divide and conquer the entire…What rules did Hamechaber set to himself before compiling the Shulchan Aruch?Shulchan Aruch UTF-8Anonymous glosses in the Shulchan AruchWhy is the Shulchan Aruch definitive?Siman 32, Kitzur Shulchan Aruch: UntranslatedLitvaks/Yeshivish and Shulchan AruchBuying a Shulchan AruchEnglish version of SHULCHAN ARUCHIs there any place where Shulchan Aruch rules with the Rosh against the Rif and Rambam?5th part of the shulchan aruchLearning to translate the Shulchan Aruch
Generally speaking, R' Yosef Karo doesn't quote authorities by name in his Shulchan Aruch, but rather focuses on what the halacha is in the Shulchan Aruch and leaves the various opinions and rationales to be explained in his Beis Yosef.
In going through Hilchos Pesach, I stumbled upon the first exception I've seen to this, in OC 460:2 (translation is Sefaria's):
הרא"ש היה משתדל במצת מצוה ועומד על עשיית' ומזרז העוסקים ומסייע בהן בעריכתן
The R"ASH would personally deliberate on the Matzot Mitzvah and oversee the production, inspire those working and assisting them in the flattening [of the dough].
Is this unique in the Shulchan Aruch, or are there other places where he refers to an authority by name?
shulchan-aruch
edited Apr 9 at 7:27
Al Berko
6,5782529
asked Apr 8 at 23:22
DonielFDonielF
17.3k12691
add a comment |
Generally speaking, R' Yosef Karo doesn't quote authorities by name in his Shulchan Aruch, but rather focuses on what the halacha is in the Shulchan Aruch and leaves the various opinions and rationales to be explained in his Beis Yosef.
In going through Hilchos Pesach, I stumbled upon the first exception I've seen to this, in OC 460:2 (translation is Sefaria's):
הרא"ש היה משתדל במצת מצוה ועומד על עשיית' ומזרז העוסקים ומסייע בהן בעריכתן
The R"ASH would personally deliberate on the Matzot Mitzvah and oversee the production, inspire those working and assisting them in the flattening [of the dough].
Is this unique in the Shulchan Aruch, or are there other places where he refers to an authority by name?
shulchan-aruch
edited Apr 9 at 7:27
Al Berko
6,5782529
asked Apr 8 at 23:22
DonielFDonielF
17.3k12691
I’d imagine opinions are cited by tefilin
– Dr. Shmuel
Apr 9 at 0:34
2
There are dozens of such examples
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:50
In general, do you imply Hamechaber had a systematic approach to writing S"A - like mentioning some and ignoring others?
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:29
Related (just posted) judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/101696/…
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:36
add a comment |
Generally speaking, R' Yosef Karo doesn't quote authorities by name in his Shulchan Aruch, but rather focuses on what the halacha is in the Shulchan Aruch and leaves the various opinions and rationales to be explained in his Beis Yosef.
In going through Hilchos Pesach, I stumbled upon the first exception I've seen to this, in OC 460:2 (translation is Sefaria's):
הרא"ש היה משתדל במצת מצוה ועומד על עשיית' ומזרז העוסקים ומסייע בהן בעריכתן
The R"ASH would personally deliberate on the Matzot Mitzvah and oversee the production, inspire those working and assisting them in the flattening [of the dough].
Is this unique in the Shulchan Aruch, or are there other places where he refers to an authority by name?
shulchan-aruch
edited Apr 9 at 7:27
Al Berko
6,5782529
asked Apr 8 at 23:22
DonielFDonielF
17.3k12691
Generally speaking, R' Yosef Karo doesn't quote authorities by name in his Shulchan Aruch, but rather focuses on what the halacha is in the Shulchan Aruch and leaves the various opinions and rationales to be explained in his Beis Yosef.
In going through Hilchos Pesach, I stumbled upon the first exception I've seen to this, in OC 460:2 (translation is Sefaria's):
הרא"ש היה משתדל במצת מצוה ועומד על עשיית' ומזרז העוסקים ומסייע בהן בעריכתן
The R"ASH would personally deliberate on the Matzot Mitzvah and oversee the production, inspire those working and assisting them in the flattening [of the dough].
Is this unique in the Shulchan Aruch, or are there other places where he refers to an authority by name?
shulchan-aruch
shulchan-aruch
edited Apr 9 at 7:27
Al Berko
6,5782529
asked Apr 8 at 23:22
DonielFDonielF
17.3k12691
edited Apr 9 at 7:27
Al Berko
6,5782529
asked Apr 8 at 23:22
DonielFDonielF
17.3k12691
edited Apr 9 at 7:27
Al Berko
6,5782529
edited Apr 9 at 7:27
Al Berko
6,5782529
edited Apr 9 at 7:27
Al Berko
6,5782529
6,5782529
asked Apr 8 at 23:22
DonielFDonielF
17.3k12691
asked Apr 8 at 23:22
DonielFDonielF
17.3k12691
asked Apr 8 at 23:22
DonielFDonielF
17.3k12691
17.3k12691
I’d imagine opinions are cited by tefilin
– Dr. Shmuel
Apr 9 at 0:34
2
There are dozens of such examples
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:50
In general, do you imply Hamechaber had a systematic approach to writing S"A - like mentioning some and ignoring others?
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:29
Related (just posted) judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/101696/…
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:36
add a comment |
I’d imagine opinions are cited by tefilin
– Dr. Shmuel
Apr 9 at 0:34
2
There are dozens of such examples
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:50
In general, do you imply Hamechaber had a systematic approach to writing S"A - like mentioning some and ignoring others?
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:29
Related (just posted) judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/101696/…
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:36
I’d imagine opinions are cited by tefilin
– Dr. Shmuel
Apr 9 at 0:34
I’d imagine opinions are cited by tefilin
– Dr. Shmuel
Apr 9 at 0:34
2
2
There are dozens of such examples
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:50
There are dozens of such examples
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:50
In general, do you imply Hamechaber had a systematic approach to writing S"A - like mentioning some and ignoring others?
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:29
In general, do you imply Hamechaber had a systematic approach to writing S"A - like mentioning some and ignoring others?
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:29
Related (just posted) judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/101696/…
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:36
Related (just posted) judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/101696/…
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:36
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
It's actually not that rare for the Shulchan Aruch to mention authorities by name. Here are a bunch of examples of different authorities mentioned:
In O.C. 34:1 he mentions a dispute involving Rashi, Rambam, and Rabbeinu Tam:
סדר הנחתן בבתיםלרש"י והרמב"ם קדש משמאל המניח בבית החיצון ואחריו כי יביאך בבית שני ושמע בבית השלישי והיה אם שמוע בבית הרביעי שהוא בית החיצון ב לימינו ולר"ת בבית השלישי והיה אם שמוע ובבית הרביעי שהוא החיצון שמע ומנהג העולם כרש"י והרמב"ם
In O.C. 185:5 he mentions an uncertainty that Tosafos and the Rosh had:
ואם בירך והיתה צואה כנגדו או שהיה שכור (פי' לגמרי) נסתפקו התוספות והרא"ש אם צריך לחזור ולברך ומשום מי רגלים פשיטא שאינו חוזר לברך
In O.C. 320:14 he mentions a dispute between R. Meir of Rothenberg and the Rosh:
הר"מ מרוטנבורג מתיר להטיל מי רגלים בשלג והרא"ש היה נזהר
O.C. 591:6 he mentions that the Ran and the Rosh defended a custom:
והרא"ש והר"ן כתבו לקיים המנהג
There are many other examples of this, some where multiple authorities are listed together or contrasted, and some where only one authority is cited.
answered Apr 9 at 0:56
AlexAlex
23.8k157135
add a comment |
Here's a double naming in hilchos muktza:
הרשב"א מתיר לטלטל האיצטרלו"ב בשבת וכן ספרי החכמה ולדעת הרמב"ם יש להסתפק בדבר:
answered Apr 9 at 0:18
user6591user6591
25.8k12758
This one always stands out in my mind as the basis of the machlokes is arguably not in line with what we would say is each rabbi's philosophy about science.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:22
First thing to pop on my mind
– sam
Apr 9 at 0:24
There are dozens of such examples. The important thing to say in an answer is that it happens dozens of times. An example is helpful but not the primary info requested
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:53
1
@Double it's true there are many. I'm not sure based on his language what his primary goal was.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:55
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
It's actually not that rare for the Shulchan Aruch to mention authorities by name. Here are a bunch of examples of different authorities mentioned:
In O.C. 34:1 he mentions a dispute involving Rashi, Rambam, and Rabbeinu Tam:
סדר הנחתן בבתיםלרש"י והרמב"ם קדש משמאל המניח בבית החיצון ואחריו כי יביאך בבית שני ושמע בבית השלישי והיה אם שמוע בבית הרביעי שהוא בית החיצון ב לימינו ולר"ת בבית השלישי והיה אם שמוע ובבית הרביעי שהוא החיצון שמע ומנהג העולם כרש"י והרמב"ם
In O.C. 185:5 he mentions an uncertainty that Tosafos and the Rosh had:
ואם בירך והיתה צואה כנגדו או שהיה שכור (פי' לגמרי) נסתפקו התוספות והרא"ש אם צריך לחזור ולברך ומשום מי רגלים פשיטא שאינו חוזר לברך
In O.C. 320:14 he mentions a dispute between R. Meir of Rothenberg and the Rosh:
הר"מ מרוטנבורג מתיר להטיל מי רגלים בשלג והרא"ש היה נזהר
O.C. 591:6 he mentions that the Ran and the Rosh defended a custom:
והרא"ש והר"ן כתבו לקיים המנהג
There are many other examples of this, some where multiple authorities are listed together or contrasted, and some where only one authority is cited.
answered Apr 9 at 0:56
AlexAlex
23.8k157135
add a comment |
It's actually not that rare for the Shulchan Aruch to mention authorities by name. Here are a bunch of examples of different authorities mentioned:
In O.C. 34:1 he mentions a dispute involving Rashi, Rambam, and Rabbeinu Tam:
סדר הנחתן בבתיםלרש"י והרמב"ם קדש משמאל המניח בבית החיצון ואחריו כי יביאך בבית שני ושמע בבית השלישי והיה אם שמוע בבית הרביעי שהוא בית החיצון ב לימינו ולר"ת בבית השלישי והיה אם שמוע ובבית הרביעי שהוא החיצון שמע ומנהג העולם כרש"י והרמב"ם
In O.C. 185:5 he mentions an uncertainty that Tosafos and the Rosh had:
ואם בירך והיתה צואה כנגדו או שהיה שכור (פי' לגמרי) נסתפקו התוספות והרא"ש אם צריך לחזור ולברך ומשום מי רגלים פשיטא שאינו חוזר לברך
In O.C. 320:14 he mentions a dispute between R. Meir of Rothenberg and the Rosh:
הר"מ מרוטנבורג מתיר להטיל מי רגלים בשלג והרא"ש היה נזהר
O.C. 591:6 he mentions that the Ran and the Rosh defended a custom:
והרא"ש והר"ן כתבו לקיים המנהג
There are many other examples of this, some where multiple authorities are listed together or contrasted, and some where only one authority is cited.
answered Apr 9 at 0:56
AlexAlex
23.8k157135
add a comment |
It's actually not that rare for the Shulchan Aruch to mention authorities by name. Here are a bunch of examples of different authorities mentioned:
In O.C. 34:1 he mentions a dispute involving Rashi, Rambam, and Rabbeinu Tam:
סדר הנחתן בבתיםלרש"י והרמב"ם קדש משמאל המניח בבית החיצון ואחריו כי יביאך בבית שני ושמע בבית השלישי והיה אם שמוע בבית הרביעי שהוא בית החיצון ב לימינו ולר"ת בבית השלישי והיה אם שמוע ובבית הרביעי שהוא החיצון שמע ומנהג העולם כרש"י והרמב"ם
In O.C. 185:5 he mentions an uncertainty that Tosafos and the Rosh had:
ואם בירך והיתה צואה כנגדו או שהיה שכור (פי' לגמרי) נסתפקו התוספות והרא"ש אם צריך לחזור ולברך ומשום מי רגלים פשיטא שאינו חוזר לברך
In O.C. 320:14 he mentions a dispute between R. Meir of Rothenberg and the Rosh:
הר"מ מרוטנבורג מתיר להטיל מי רגלים בשלג והרא"ש היה נזהר
O.C. 591:6 he mentions that the Ran and the Rosh defended a custom:
והרא"ש והר"ן כתבו לקיים המנהג
There are many other examples of this, some where multiple authorities are listed together or contrasted, and some where only one authority is cited.
answered Apr 9 at 0:56
AlexAlex
23.8k157135
It's actually not that rare for the Shulchan Aruch to mention authorities by name. Here are a bunch of examples of different authorities mentioned:
In O.C. 34:1 he mentions a dispute involving Rashi, Rambam, and Rabbeinu Tam:
סדר הנחתן בבתיםלרש"י והרמב"ם קדש משמאל המניח בבית החיצון ואחריו כי יביאך בבית שני ושמע בבית השלישי והיה אם שמוע בבית הרביעי שהוא בית החיצון ב לימינו ולר"ת בבית השלישי והיה אם שמוע ובבית הרביעי שהוא החיצון שמע ומנהג העולם כרש"י והרמב"ם
In O.C. 185:5 he mentions an uncertainty that Tosafos and the Rosh had:
ואם בירך והיתה צואה כנגדו או שהיה שכור (פי' לגמרי) נסתפקו התוספות והרא"ש אם צריך לחזור ולברך ומשום מי רגלים פשיטא שאינו חוזר לברך
In O.C. 320:14 he mentions a dispute between R. Meir of Rothenberg and the Rosh:
הר"מ מרוטנבורג מתיר להטיל מי רגלים בשלג והרא"ש היה נזהר
O.C. 591:6 he mentions that the Ran and the Rosh defended a custom:
והרא"ש והר"ן כתבו לקיים המנהג
There are many other examples of this, some where multiple authorities are listed together or contrasted, and some where only one authority is cited.
answered Apr 9 at 0:56
AlexAlex
23.8k157135
answered Apr 9 at 0:56
AlexAlex
23.8k157135
answered Apr 9 at 0:56
AlexAlex
23.8k157135
answered Apr 9 at 0:56
AlexAlex
23.8k157135
23.8k157135
add a comment |
add a comment |
Here's a double naming in hilchos muktza:
הרשב"א מתיר לטלטל האיצטרלו"ב בשבת וכן ספרי החכמה ולדעת הרמב"ם יש להסתפק בדבר:
answered Apr 9 at 0:18
user6591user6591
25.8k12758
This one always stands out in my mind as the basis of the machlokes is arguably not in line with what we would say is each rabbi's philosophy about science.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:22
First thing to pop on my mind
– sam
Apr 9 at 0:24
There are dozens of such examples. The important thing to say in an answer is that it happens dozens of times. An example is helpful but not the primary info requested
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:53
1
@Double it's true there are many. I'm not sure based on his language what his primary goal was.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:55
add a comment |
Here's a double naming in hilchos muktza:
הרשב"א מתיר לטלטל האיצטרלו"ב בשבת וכן ספרי החכמה ולדעת הרמב"ם יש להסתפק בדבר:
answered Apr 9 at 0:18
user6591user6591
25.8k12758
This one always stands out in my mind as the basis of the machlokes is arguably not in line with what we would say is each rabbi's philosophy about science.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:22
First thing to pop on my mind
– sam
Apr 9 at 0:24
There are dozens of such examples. The important thing to say in an answer is that it happens dozens of times. An example is helpful but not the primary info requested
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:53
1
@Double it's true there are many. I'm not sure based on his language what his primary goal was.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:55
add a comment |
Here's a double naming in hilchos muktza:
הרשב"א מתיר לטלטל האיצטרלו"ב בשבת וכן ספרי החכמה ולדעת הרמב"ם יש להסתפק בדבר:
answered Apr 9 at 0:18
user6591user6591
25.8k12758
Here's a double naming in hilchos muktza:
הרשב"א מתיר לטלטל האיצטרלו"ב בשבת וכן ספרי החכמה ולדעת הרמב"ם יש להסתפק בדבר:
answered Apr 9 at 0:18
user6591user6591
25.8k12758
answered Apr 9 at 0:18
user6591user6591
25.8k12758
answered Apr 9 at 0:18
user6591user6591
25.8k12758
answered Apr 9 at 0:18
user6591user6591
25.8k12758
25.8k12758
This one always stands out in my mind as the basis of the machlokes is arguably not in line with what we would say is each rabbi's philosophy about science.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:22
First thing to pop on my mind
– sam
Apr 9 at 0:24
There are dozens of such examples. The important thing to say in an answer is that it happens dozens of times. An example is helpful but not the primary info requested
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:53
1
@Double it's true there are many. I'm not sure based on his language what his primary goal was.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:55
add a comment |
This one always stands out in my mind as the basis of the machlokes is arguably not in line with what we would say is each rabbi's philosophy about science.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:22
First thing to pop on my mind
– sam
Apr 9 at 0:24
There are dozens of such examples. The important thing to say in an answer is that it happens dozens of times. An example is helpful but not the primary info requested
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:53
1
@Double it's true there are many. I'm not sure based on his language what his primary goal was.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:55
This one always stands out in my mind as the basis of the machlokes is arguably not in line with what we would say is each rabbi's philosophy about science.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:22
This one always stands out in my mind as the basis of the machlokes is arguably not in line with what we would say is each rabbi's philosophy about science.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:22
First thing to pop on my mind
– sam
Apr 9 at 0:24
First thing to pop on my mind
– sam
Apr 9 at 0:24
There are dozens of such examples. The important thing to say in an answer is that it happens dozens of times. An example is helpful but not the primary info requested
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:53
There are dozens of such examples. The important thing to say in an answer is that it happens dozens of times. An example is helpful but not the primary info requested
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:53
1
1
@Double it's true there are many. I'm not sure based on his language what his primary goal was.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:55
@Double it's true there are many. I'm not sure based on his language what his primary goal was.
– user6591
Apr 9 at 0:55
add a comment |
I’d imagine opinions are cited by tefilin
– Dr. Shmuel
Apr 9 at 0:34
2
There are dozens of such examples
– Double AA♦
Apr 9 at 0:50
In general, do you imply Hamechaber had a systematic approach to writing S"A - like mentioning some and ignoring others?
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:29
Related (just posted) judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/101696/…
– Al Berko
Apr 9 at 7:36